Getting people to exercise is one thing, but getting them to adhere to a workout plan is another. EcFit (pronounced like ‘easy fit’) systems by Extracon Science promises to provide “automatic reminders and coaching by phone.” EcFit is a technology-based tracking system that helps you stick to your workouts by calling you to see that you’re meeting your monthly adherence goals. In other words, are you working out when you say you are.
The concept is simple. Select your adherence goal. Mine was completing 80% of my scheduled workouts. Then schedule your workouts on the EcFit website. Finally, select the best times you want EcFit to call you to receive the calls that help keep track of workout attendance. You can set the call (and text-message) to come BEFORE your workout so it can remind you of your upcoming appointment. Or, set the call to ring you AFTER your workout so you can confirm whether or not you’ve completed your exercise. You can also call EcFit when you’ve completed an unscheduled workout. (Check out the demo here.)
Now, in theory this all sounds great. A system to keep you accountable for your workouts. But does it really improve exercise adherence? I’ve spent the past 3 weeks testing out this system and here’s what i found.
Automatic reminders: this was a very valuable feature. For me, I set most of my reminders BEFORE my workouts (especially if they were early morning ones because then the call & text-message coupled as a wake-up call, too! LOL). Although I found the reminders effective, I can’t seem to justify paying their $5 monthly fee for sending me automated reminders. (Especially when there are other free resources online, such as WakerUpper, Memo2me, or HassleMe that do pretty much the same thing.)
Virtual coach by phone: I didn’t find this to be effective for me. EcFit called me at the scheduled prompts, requiring I give feedback on my workout attendance. “Yes, I attended” or “No, I didn’t.” It gave me my progress based on my answers. “You have completed 71% of your scheduled workouts. You are not meeting your goal of 80%. If you complete the next 13 workouts you will meet your goal by September 21st.” I love collecting data and seeing the stats about my workouts. But, I’ll be honest, these stats seemed arbitrary to me. Especially when during the next scheduled call, it told me completing 2 more workouts would keep me on target. What caused this discrepancy? What was their point of reference? This didn’t motivate me, it frustrated me. But regardless of these variable results, I still wasn’t convinced that obtaining numerical statistics were the key to long-term exercise adherence. After a while, I started sending EcFit’s phone calls to voicemail. And I didn’t care if I was completing 50% or 92% of my workouts – I was just happy that I was completing my workouts.
EcFit’s system is supported by research done at Stanford University. According to the information on the EcFit brochure, the conclusion from the study found that automated calling systems were an effective, low-cost way to increase exercise in sedentary adults over 55. (Health Psychology, 2007, Nov Vol 26 (6) 718-727). I actually found and read this study. I realized that the ‘automated calling system’ or telephone-linked computer (TLC) system the research referred to had delivered counseling content consistent with that of an in-person health educator. This meant that the counseling provided via TLC included “physical activity assessment, progress evaluation, individualized problem-solving, goal-setting, feedback, and delivery of positive support and tailored advice.” Hardly equivalent to the service EcFit provides.
Effective use of technology can prove essential in health promotion and exercise adherence. We’re seeing more web-based and mobile-centric programs that are helping those who need to overcome barriers blocking their paths to healthful living. I believe EcFit is doing their part in helping people make baby steps towards committing to a health behavior. Although I had hoped for more, given the climate of the internet with its web 2.0 technologies, I walked away a bit underwhelmed.
If EcFit can accommodate the techno-savvy generation of today’s online world, I see no reason why it couldn’t be a leader in “technology-based services that enable people to make healthy changes in their lives.” But for now, I’d suggest going to Wellsphere if you want to experience some of these similar features for free!